
The New Space is Finally Open a Year after the Hurricanes
After Hurricane Helene dumped nearly six feet of water into the Don CeSar on St. Pete Beach on September 26, 2024, they finally reopened the hotel on March 28, 2025. Right around the time the hurricane hit was when the Don’s newly revamped restaurant, Society Table was opening. We were actually tentatively scheduled to go after they figuratively got their feet wet in the kitchen. Unfortunately, they almost literally got their feet wet. Society table was literally under water. It would take two weeks shy of a year to get the original space running again. On Monday, September 8, 2025 the new permanent space with the expanded full menu will launch.
The Don CeSar decided to temporarily close their fine dining restaurant Maritana and let Society Table operate out of that space until their five times larger space was ready. Lori and I dined in the temporary Society Table / Maritana space last week so we could give you a preview of what’s to come. If you’re a Maritana fan, they will reclaim their space on Wednesday Sept 17th with a new menu and new Chef de Cuisine – Chef David Martin-Garcia. He is originally from Spain but most recently the Edition Hotel in Tampa. The Executive Chef of the Don is Chef Alexander Reyes.
Full disclosure: We were invited and treated to dinner by Chef de Cuisine Susan Burdian. This does not affect our review. While most of the review is well-deserved praise, there is criticism. We thought the Peruvian chicken was dry, and the yogurt sauce with the wings quite tart. You will see some tasting portions that are smaller than the regular portion, and this will be noted.
Spicy Ahi Tuna – crispy rice cake, ginger-tamari reduction, spicy aioli, avocado. This is a delicious welcome take on ahi tuna. The tuna is minced with ginger and citrus, then formed into a quenelle shape. It is placed on top of fried crispy sushi rice. The sushi rice cake gives the dish nice texture. Avocado crema sits in between the tuna and rice. A spicy mayo drizzle serves as garnish for added flavor and creamy mouthfeel. Anything that comes with a lemon or lime wedge means you are supposed to squeeze it over the top. Be sure to do so with the lime. Tasting portion shown. The regular portion comes with three pieces. Lori loved it. I liked it.
Shrimp & Orecchiette – orecchiette pasta, Key West pink shrimp – butterflied and sautéed, tarragon cream sauce, sweet peas, cauliflower. When you bite into the shrimp they are firm and springy with the perfect gentle snap. The orecchiette with their al dente chew and little cup of sauce were hard to stop eating. I loved it. Lori liked it. Tasting portion shown.
Dynamite Shrimp – this is Society Table’s answer to Bang-Bang Shrimp. Lori said it was better than Bang-Bang shrimp which she considers to be too sweet. The sauce is nicely balanced with a little bit of heat. The shrimp maintain a crispy texture even after being tossed in the sauce. There is a drizzle of sambal sauce on the plate and the toasted cashews were a nice touch, complementing with more crunch and nuttiness. Roasted cauliflower completes the balancing act of textures and flavors.

Market Green Salad – house greens (in this case baby gem, frisée and arugula), fresh herbs, cucumber, green apple, jalapeño, avocado, orange supremes, ginger vinaigrette. This salad was immaculate. It has such a wonderful assortment of different textures and flavors that it hits all of the senses – it looks beautiful, has a great crunch, and it’s aromatic with sweet, sour, tart, and salty notes. I never knew that jalapeño and green apple made such a great flavor combination. Tasting portion shown.

The 1855 Farm black angus skirt steak was one of our favorite dishes. We fell in love with skirt steak, in general, a long time ago. It’s a thin cut that is super tender and moist when cooked correctly. It can be tricky. It needs high heat and a fast cook to get a nice sear while keeping the inside rare to medium-rare. This steak was done perfectly. Seasoned simply with salt and pepper it would already be a great steak.
However, Society Table adds some extra refinement and tons of extra flavor by crafting a subtle five-spice ponzu seasoning. These are two huge flavor boosters working together. The steak sits on top of “peasant-fried rice” which is not a specific known recipe, but I do know that peasants usually come up with some tasty stuff and so did the chef. This is fun because the rice looks plain and simple, unlike a fried rice with lots of leftovers thrown in, but it is packed with flavor. I had to ask the chef what the magic was, and now it makes sense – ginger, garlic, sesame oil, a little brown sugar, Thai chilis, fish sauce, and Thai basil. That’s flavor on top of flavor that is perfectly balanced.
The steak is topped with a fried egg that is appropriately done the Asian way with a crispy, golden-brown edge and a runny yolk.
Note: 1855 Farm is one of the top suppliers of purebred premium Black Angus beef, known for its marbling, tenderness, and flavor. Cattle come from family-owned ranches in the grain-rich Great Plains, known for raising high-quality Black Angus. Their beef is processed under uniform standards at only four facilities in the United States, ensuring consistent quality. The number “1855” is a tribute to Gustavus Swift, who started the Swift meat packing company in 1855 and is credited with pioneering the modern meat industry.
Before it hit your plate, the Black Gulf Grouper was swimming in the same waters that are right outside of the restaurant. It doesn’t get more local or fresh than that. It is pan seared with a light blackening seasoning and is buttery and flakey. This hearty fillet sits on a bed of succotash that consists of marble potatoes, cherry tomatoes, charred corn, and lima beans. I’ve never had fresh lima beans before. What a huge difference than frozen. I love succotash, and I really love this one. At the base, we have what the menu describes as a “low country beurre blanc”. Our server, Don (just like the hotel – that’s how he introduces himself in his baritone voice) who was excellent by the way, told us that the beurre blanc consists of white wine, garlic, shallots, and lemon juice. I asked Chef Susan what makes it “Low Country”, and she said there’s just a touch of Frank’s RedHot sauce. What a great idea! It’s not a spicy sauce overall if that’s a concern. There is some herb oil drizzled onto the sauce, and the fish is topped with fried okra. I would say that qualifies for low country status too. This was another one of my favorite dishes.
We don’t find a lot of Peruvian food in this area, which makes the Peruvian Chicken Skewers perfect if you’re looking for something different with a Latin twist. The chicken breast is cubed and marinated overnight with coriander, cumin, smoked paprika, and other spices. It is then skewered and grilled and plated over lime-scented rice, with smoky black beans, and sweet plantains. Aji verde sauce is on the side for dipping. Tasting portion shown. The regular portion comes with two skewers, drizzled with aji verde, and a a full plate of rice and beans. All of the supporting actors were excellent. The chicken being the star of the show had good flavor, but it was a little dry, which often happens with breast.

If you’re a fan of chicken wings, then you must try the Smoked Chicken Wings. The smokiness, which comes from oak and apple woods, is just the right amount to enhance the flavor without overpowering. After smoking, the wings are tossed in an approachable Buffalo-coconut glaze. The lime yogurt on the side offers a tart palate refresh and balances out the smoke and sauce. It is quite tart, so prepare yourself. It is a fun contrast though. The pickled okra brings things full circle.
For a refreshing, but satisfyingly filling item, the crab toast does the trick. The flavors are light, bright, citrusy and fresh. The crab salad is simply done with jumbo lump crab, salt, pepper, and house-made mayo. It sits on a thick slice of toasted brioche that is first spread with corn nage that gives it a hint of sweet smokiness. (The corn is roasted in the husks, and then charred with flame. It is then sautéed with yellow onions, and blended with cream and butter. This is a creamy French sauce that is typically served with seafood.) Grapefruit supremes nicely top it off with a bright tart citrus note.
The crab toast was good, but the crab cakes are  great. They use no bread crumb filler. To bind the lump crab, lemon, celery, and mayo – a little egg does the trick. The mayo helps hold it together too. Thanks to the light panko crust, the first bite gives a delicate crispness with a tender interior highlighting big, juicy lumps of crab that gently flake apart. The crab is sweet, briny and clean. The lemon brightens with a citrus lift and the celery adds a subtle crunch and freshness. The roasted red pepper remoulade adds a smoky-sweet depth with a touch of tang and spice, creating a vivid contrast to the light, sweet crab meat. The grapefruit supremes and frisée complete the flavor balancing. The above crab cakes were 2 oz tasting portions. The entree will be two 4 oz crab cakes.
Pastry Chef Amanda Santos delighted us with her chocolate tart dessert – malted mousse, cookie butter crisp, dulce chantilly, cocoa nib gelato.
This dish balances rich and light elements beautifully. The glossy tart gives way to airy malted mousse with a crunchy crisp base, all in a buttery cocoa shell. Dulce chantilly adds caramel creaminess, while the cool, bittersweet cocoa nib gelato with chocolate soil cuts the richness. Each bite layers crisp, creamy, warm-cold, and bitter-sweet contrasts for an elegant, indulgent finish.
Society Table and Rowe Bar Menus
Refined American plates with local seafood and great steaks with some Asian, Italian, Latino, and American-Southern influences throughout.
PLEASE NOTE: Reviews reflect a certain moment in time. Some restaurants stay extremely consistent over many years, and some change for the better or worse. Some things that may change are: chefs, recipes, food suppliers, ingredients, philosophies, ownership, etc. We always hope that you have the same good, or great experience we had.