
All the buzz lately has been about the new restaurant at the historic Vinoy Resort and Golf Club named Elliott Aster. That buzz is definitely warranted. We had an excellent dinner there last week that we were still talking about the next day. Looking around the nearly full room, you would never know that it is the slow summer season.
Chef Lee Wolen and Boka Restaurant Group have partnered with the Vinoy for what I think is the best restaurant the resort has ever had.
Chef Wolen earned a Michelin star for Boka restaurant in Chicago (which they have maintained from 2011-2025), so maybe he’ll get one for Elliott Aster as well. We dined at Boka last December and it was certainly a Michelin star level experience.
Chef Wolen resides in Chicago. He wasn’t there the evening we dined, but he was coming in on the weekend. We did have the pleasure of meeting the Chef de Cuisine Penny Barend Tagliarina when she shaved truffles for us.
The restaurant takes the first part of its name from Gene Elliott. He was the real estate developer who conceived of the idea to build the hotel and to name it Vinoy after the original owner Aymer Vinoy Laughner. The second part of the restaurant’s name comes from the lavender wildflower native to Florida named Aster.
The elegant grandness of the space is immediately evident as you enter with the high ceilings, chandeliers, long flowing drapery, and a massive wall of liquor that beckons you to imbibe.

There is a lounge area in the front and along the left and right perimeters. The bar divides the dining room in two, and in back there is a charcuterie and antipasti bar serving freshly sliced Italian meats, whipped ricotta, and marinated vegetables. (You can see some of it in the background of the next two photos of drinks.)
As per custom, we started with drinks. Both the Sweet Heat Paloma and the Elliott Aster Martini were excellent. The Sweet Heat Paloma has spicy blanco tequila, Cappelletti Aperitivo, grapefruit, lime, and soda.
The Elliott Aster Martini has Tanqueray No. 10 gin, dry vermouth, and celery bitters. It also comes with an extra half-pour in a small carafe on the side.
The Kanpachi Crudo is light and refreshing. The flavors brought by the blood orange and olive oil co-mingle perfectly with the basil aroma awakening your senses, and the blood orange supremes’ texture burst when you bite into it contrasts perfectly with the thinly sliced amberjack’s buttery silky finish that makes this dish a winner.
We got burnt out on octopus a few years ago after it seemed like every restaurant suddenly added it to their menu like there was some secret meeting. This dish fixed that problem. It’s one of the best octopus dishes I’ve had in a long time. It was super tender, which is not easy to do. The unique preparation, using eggplant, salmoriglio sauce, and garlic aioli, made it addicting. I almost couldn’t stop shoveling it into my mouth.

The whipped ricotta is the perfect example of how something so simple can taste so lovely. It was silky smooth and delightfully creamy, perfectly straddling the line between sweet and savory. The savory crispy, crunchy flatbread crisps were an excellent pairing.
There is a pasta section on the menu with six items and we wanted to try them all. All of the pasta is scratch made in-house. We tried two with the first one being the Ricotta & Corn Ravioli (with Australian black winter truffle add-on) and chanterelle mushrooms, parmesan cheese, and brown butter.
I couldn’t stop eating this one either. The hand-stuffed ravioli was pillowy, and the combination of corn, brown butter, mushrooms, chives, and cheese formed an addicting, savory dish with subtle hints of sweetness.
Beef cheek is a cut that gets a long, slow braise to build massive flavors and then becomes fall apart delicious. Shred that up and stuff it into fresh made pasta and you have a winner.
There is so much perfection happening at Elliott Astor. The prime ribeye was perfectly seasoned, perfectly seared, and almost perfectly cooked. It was a tad over for medium-rare, but still looked beautiful and tasted excellent. We didn’t say anything for such a small bit over and we still loved it. This excellent quality beef comes from Châtel Farms in Reidsville, GA.
The Lacquered Brick Chicken with foie gras chicken jus, beech mushrooms, and watercress is the sleeper standout dish. Our server Emily, who took great care of us, told us that it wasn’t getting ordered much.
I understand that people don’t often order chicken when out to dinner, especially in a fancy restaurant.
You should definitely order this. It will be the best chicken you’ve ever had.
The dish deceivingly seems simple, but it is a complex masterpiece in flavor and culinary technique. It seems a little pricey at $52, but it is worth it.
The chicken comes from renowned poultry supplier Jurgielewicz Farm in Berks County, Pennsylvania.
Brick chicken is a method of cooking chicken that results in incredibly crispy skin and juicy, flavorful meat. This happens because the brick flattens the chicken, increasing the surface area of the skin that comes into contact with the hot pan. It also cooks the chicken faster, keeping the inside moist. This was chicken breast that ate as juicy as thighs.
The foie gras chicken jus is the trick to putting this one over the top, and it requires a substantial amount of work, care, and time.
First you have to make the chicken jus. This involves roasting chicken bones with vegetables like carrots, onions, and celery to caramelize them, then simmering them with herbs and water to extract their flavors. After cooking for an hour, this then gets reduced for eight hours, then it’s strained, resulting in a concentrated, flavorful jus.
But it’s not done yet. The foie gras still needs to be incorporated. Puréed foie gras now needs to be whisked into the chicken jus to create the final sauce that is packed with flavor.
Note: This is from my knowledge of how this would be done, not exactly how the restaurant does it. I asked for confirmation days after our dinner, but did not receive a response as they were quite busy with a packed house.
Anyway, get the chicken.
The crispy fingerling potatoes were unfortunately dry and needed more seasoning. I imagine that is an anomaly that just slipped through the cracks on this night of otherwise spectacular food.
The olive oil torta has a moist, tender crumb that’s physically heavy – in a good way from being soaked with olive oil. It is moist with a nice chew. It has just the right amount of lemon tanginess perfectly balanced with a subtle earthiness from the olive oil. The mascarpone is rich and creamy, yet light in flavor and the blueberry compote rounds it out with some nice tartness. This is a really great piece of cake.
The Salted Caramel & Coffee Budino with caramelized white chocolate, and Caffee Borghetti is a no-brainer. If you can’t decide what to get for dessert – get this.
The chocolate budino is rich, creamy, and decadent with an intense chocolate flavor and a velvety, smooth texture. The chocolate and coffee crumble topping offer a delightful crunch and slightly bitter contrast to the rich, silky, and sweet budino. This is another one that was hard to stop eating and should be a crowd pleaser.
With all of the dishes we had, there are still several that we can’t wait to try when we go back next month.
Elliott Aster welcomes guests in smart casual attire.
An elegant, upscale restaurant and bar at the historic Vinoy Hotel by the acclaimed Boka Restaurant Group.
PLEASE NOTE: Reviews reflect a certain moment in time. Some restaurants stay extremely consistent over many years, and some change for the better or worse. Some things that may change are: chefs, recipes, food suppliers, ingredients, philosophies, ownership, etc. We always hope that you have the same good, or great experience we had.