Nicko’s: St. Pete’s Newest Pizza Joint May be the Best Yet
-
Lori Brown - Apr 28, 2022
- 5 min read
Talk around town was that Nicko’s Pizza and Subs was the real deal, so we decided we had to see what the buzz was all about. When we first visited in March, they had to discontinue delivery due to being too busy with take out and in the restaurant itself. Currently, you can now order delivery on their website or through GrubHub, which I am doing today, to get the picture of their famous Steak and Cheese Deluxe that I devoured, before I got the picture, the second time we were there.
This unassuming southside restaurant, which just opened the first of February, definitely stands up to all of the hype and more.
Nicko is a native Floridian from Indian Rocks Beach and he went to Largo High School.
I couldn’t have written this better so this is the about page from their website, “Nicko’s was founded by power couple Erin and Nick Faraone, who have worked tirelessly to bring this magical land of flavors to life. Nick, a man with a passion for the savory and a legacy from his father (also named Nick), who spent his lifetime crafting culinary comfort foods for the community he loved. Starting his apprenticeship at the ripe age of 10, young Nicko spent his childhood playing in seasonings and flour like other kid’s play in sandboxes. Working in his father’s restaurant he cultivated his skill with flavors and the artistry of a crunchy, flakey crust. And while pizza is on the name, don’t miss out on their specialty subs. His father made a legacy on his take of a classic sub… “He turned a Philly cheese steak into a hoagie and then geared it towards Florida” says Nicko. This sub creation has been the foundation of this multi-generational enterprise, the Steak and Cheese Deluxe is a local flair that you can’t afford to miss!”
Nicko told us this, ” I grew up in the kitchen watching my parents make pizzas. I was the kid laying on the #10 cans under the shelf, coloring in my coloring book, watching cheese and lettuce falling down on my parents’ feet. It’s just natural for me to be in the kitchen. I love it…It’s such a rewarding thing when you have the passion for it. That’s something that can really make or break you. This is a tough business but it can be amazing if you do it right.”
Nicko told us that when they first opened people would come in and get one slice of cheese pizza and then they would come back the next day for the whole pie, because that’s the best way to test it out.
We had to start with the meatballs because why? We love great meatballs! These definitely stand up to that test. They are three jumbo meatballs in marinara sauce, topped with mouth-watering melted mozzarella. You can tell they are housemade and Kevin says when he updates the best meatballs list, these will make the cut for sure. For me, they were a tad oregano forward, but that’s just me.
Just look at the inside, you can tell these are not from the freezer.
To quote myself, this Classic Cheese Pizza, that, yes, you can get by the slice, is the closest to New York pizza that I have tasted in this town. And we just returned from a New York City pizza tour in November. It is scrumptious.
According to Nicko about his pizza dough, “Everyday I am thinking about the humidity level and the temperature outside. I use cold water and sometimes my water needs to be a little colder. I don’t have an exact recipe. I even measure the salt with my hand…When I was about ten, I started learning how to form it and when I was twelve I started working on the line making pizzas.”
It even passes the New York pizza fold and orange oil drip test…
Kevin loves an Italian Sub so that’s what we ordered on our first trip. I forgot to take the picture of that one too so this is from our second trip when we got it again. Absolutely tasty and delicious. It is made with capicola, provolone, salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & vinegar dressing and cherry pepper relish. That cherry pepper relish is Nicko’s signature and let me tell you what, it just pops in your mouth in every way that is good. The bread is soft and toothsome, just the way I like it. We both highly recommend this or any sub you prefer for that matter.
We had to order another pizza as well, so we ordered a whole Supreme Pizza topped with onion, mushroom, green pepper, pepperoni, sausage, ham, mozzarella and pizza sauce and all of their pizzas can be made gluten free in the 12″ size. It is topped with the freshest of ingredients and was just as delicious when we reheated our leftovers the next day. Anyone who says crust doesn’t make a pizza, is just wrong. However, the sauce and the cheese ratio was also perfection as well as the even disbursement of the tasty toppings.
So on our second visit, as I stated in the beginning, I ordered this Steak and Cheese Deluxe, which Nicko says is so incredibly popular that he didn’t even want me to write about it (he did give me permission of course). It is a totally different take on a cheese steak it is made with shaved rib-eye, grilled onion, mushroom, roasted green peppers, mozzarella, (oven baked) and topped with lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil & vinegar dressing and cherry pepper relish. Sounds a bit weird for the cheese steak fanatics out there, right? Wrong. I am one of those fanatics and this sub changed my world. First, I had to go into it realizing that this was a totally different sub. Wow, I absolutely loved the different textures and flavors that the extra ingredients added, especially the umami from the mayo and the pop of flavor from the cherry pepper relish. Do yourself a favor and get yourself one now.
Nicko’s Pizza and Subs is a true hidden gem and worth the five minute drive south on 4th Street from downtown. Yes, it’s that close. Get yourself there!
- Readers Rating
- Rated 4.6 stars
4.6 / 5 ( Reviewers) - Outstanding
- Your Rating
- Nicko's Pizza and Subs
- 727-416-1200
- Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
- Mon - Sat 11:00am - 9:00pm
- 1239 4th St S, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, USA
A casual southside pizza and sub restaurant.
PLEASE NOTE: Reviews reflect a certain moment in time. Some restaurants stay extremely consistent over many years, and some change for the better or worse. Some things that may change are: chefs, recipes, food suppliers, ingredients, philosophies, ownership, etc. We always hope that you have the same good, or great experience we had.
Written by Lori Brown
More Foodies News, Reviews & Recipes
5 Responses
Recent Posts
After reading some wonderful things about Eat Art Love, we decided to check them out for brunch a couple of weeks ago. Located in the Warehouse Arts District at 589 22nd St S in an unassuming strip plaza, one would never guess what wonderful creations come out of this kitchen. They are currently open for brunch only Friday – Sunday from 9:00am – 3:00pm. However, starting January 8th they will be joining forces with Roy Allen who is opening Sage’s Playground (next door) to offer a full cafe experience. Sage’s offers specialty coffee, tea and seasonal drinks. The new hours starting January 8th will be Wednesday – Friday 8am – 2pm for fast casual grab and go food and caffeine fixes, and Saturday – Sunday for full service brunch from 9am – 2pm. There are plans in the works for 2025 to possibly add dinner a night or two during the week. The Executive Chef and Co-Owner is Mario Brugnoli, whose resume includes professional cooking at fine dining restaurants, including Michelin star Rocca in Tampa and Meliora in Sarasota. He has also competed on Food Network’s show Chopped. Co-Owners with Chef Mario are Jose and Natalie Martinez also owners of Sartorial, Inc in downtown St Pete. Our first visit we decided to start with one of the specialty drinks called Jess’s Spiced Green Tea Elixir made with green tea, spice infusion and rosemary. You can choose to add prosecco, which I did. It’s quite refreshing for any occasion. The interior is quaint and festive. Reservations are recommended as there are limited tables. Our first food item was the Poached Egg Dip with creamed potato and chives and served with sourdough bread for dipping. This is a wow dish and a must order to share. It’s rich, creamy and the sourdough is just dreamy as well. Next, we had to order the E.A.L. Classic which has perfectly soft-scrambled eggs, with kielbasa that has that satisfying snap when you bite into it and a juicy burst of salty flavor. The hashbrowns were quite crunchy, but a tad overcooked giving them a bit of a burnt taste. The caramelized onions and housemade spicy salsa verde rounded out the dish nicely. The Housemade Sausage Sandwich was a no brainer to try with pickled onions, Weber’s mustard and a potato roll. In my book, you can never go wrong with sausage and mustard. This was very good, but in my opinion, it could have used more mustard. On our second visit, the very next week, our friend Lisa joined us. She and I started with prosecco. Kevin ordered this highly impressive, housemade hot cocoa which came out ceremoniously with a flaming marshmallow. This was so rich and decadent. You could tell it was made in house. I would so order this again. I had my eye on the Confit Duck Leg from the get go. The grits with whipped feta were a perfect textural balance to the crispy duck skin and juicy interior. I could not really find a reason for the tomatoes. They didn’t add anything flavor wise to the dish or the visual appeal. I think it would be gorgeous and taste better without them. They just seemed out of place. The stand out star from both visits was Grandpa Larry’s Benedict which Lisa ordered. The 24 hour ragu is Mario’s grandfather’s recipe and is absolutely delicious. Combined with the eggs, garlic bread, parmesan and basil it is an outstanding, hearty dish that I can’t wait to eat again. A very cute presentation on the Fried Chicken Sandwich served in a sandwich sleeve with Chef Mario’s picture on the front. The Fried Chicken Sandwich is monstrous. It is served on a potato roll with hot honey, mayo and pickled cabbage. The chicken was fried to perfection. I am not a fan of the “hot honey” craze that it seems every chef in town is into, I would order this again without it. If you’re a savory person, like me. I would suggest that. The bun is good but had a hard time holding up to the sandwich. But again, the chicken is really the star here and it worked well. Kevin recommends cutting the sandwich in half, and then eating it from the middle. This way you get all of the flavors together at once and it’s much more enjoyable than chewing through the plain chicken alone from the outside overhang until you get to everything else. All in all, Eat Art Love is such a great addition to the Warehouse Arts district and has such a unique menu. I would highly recommend for all to support this great local spot. Eat Art Love Menu
Lajawab Indian Cuisine is a great new Indian spot in St. Pete. They opened in June 2024. (They are at 2705 54th Ave N. where ABC Seafood used to be.) It is owned by two Indian chef brothers making a wide variety of vegetarian and non-vegetarian dishes. “Lajawab” means “unmatched” or “incomparable.” It is often used to describe something that is exceptional, outstanding, or beyond comparison. Lajawab Indian Cuisine chose their name well. My Indian friend Mahika (she writes for St. Pete Foodies too) went with me for my second visit and she was quite pleased. My Pakistani friend (Pakistan used to be part of India), Brendan said, “It’s the best Indian food Pinellas has ever had!” One last quote from Bieanca, “Love this place! I just came back from India and can say the food is authentic”. Lori accompanied me for my first visit. Cilantro tastes like soap to her. It’s genetic. It completely ruins any dish. I contacted the restaurant in advance and they said said that they can make dishes for her without cilantro. This is good news for anyone else that has the same issue, as now you can try some of the best Indian food in St. Pete. The menu has some familiar favorites, but most appealing to me are the dishes that I haven’t seen or eaten before. I had the Chettinad Chicken, which I have made at home several times, but this was the first time having it in a restaurant. None of the Indian restaurants in St. Pete have it. (There are some in the surrounding area outside of St. Pete that do.) It was creamy and spicy with big chunks of chicken. They also offer lamb and goat as meat protein options, and of course have several vegetarian offerings as well. There is no butter chicken, which is a quite westernized dish, so just that makes it feel more authentic to me. I like super spicy food. To me, the Chettinad was spicy, but still approachable. It was right at Lori’s threshold for spice. She ordered the Lajawab Curry with chicken, which had mild heat, and lots of warming spices. She said she liked it better than my dish. The naan was great. The basmati rice was mildly aromatic with little bits of toasted cumin seeds here and there, and it did it’s job of soaking up the extra sauces. Lori liked their Raita better than the one I make at home, so now I need to reverse engineer the recipe for this one. They have the cucumber completely pureed in, where I keep diced chucks in it. The potato and pea samosas we started with were packed with flavor and just the right amount of medium spice. I returned a week later with Mahika figuring this would be the ultimate test. She was born in India. She spent the first ten years of her life in Australia and the second ten in India. Then she went to Paris and earned two culinary degrees. Now she is at USF St. Pete about to wrap up her journalism degree. She also writes and takes photos for this website. I went early to see if I could talk to Chef Somi, but he was already too busy. I did get to meet him after lunch though. While I waited for Mahika I snacked on papad and tried a Taj Mahal beer for the first time. Papad packs a lot of flavor in a light bite. The Taj Mahal beer has a malt-forward flavor with a subtle sweetness, and a dry finish. I quite liked it. My new favorite food is Chicken 65. It is a spicy, deep-fried chicken dish that is usually an appetizer or snack. It’s a little bit like the Buffalo Wings of India in that it is a spicy chicken appetizer that is quite popular, and it’s origin is disputed. However, Chicken 65 is boneless, spicier, and much more complex than Buffalo Wings. It’s crunchy on the outside and succulent on the inside. Curry leaves add that wonderful fresh herby fragrance, and the lightly sautéed green bell peppers and onions offer a bright and sweet contrast. Chicken 65 is one of the only dishes where you choose your spice level. The online menu offers the choices of mild, medium, or hot. However, when Mahika and I were there, our server Lily also offered extra hot. We both like a high level of heat, but we played it safe and ordered hot. Now we know that we can order extra hot next time. Be careful though. We like super spicy food. The reason you don’t designate your level of spice on most of the dishes is because each recipe already has a set flavor profile that includes a level of mild, medium, or hot and they are made the way they are supposed to be made. If you’re not sure, your server can guide you. Next up, was another extremely popular dish, Biryani Rice with Chicken. This is loaded with all kinds of flavors and is a large portion. As a side, four people could share it. Its fragrant and herby aromas reach your nose first, and then there is subtle sweetness with more savory flavors, and it is slightly spicy. The Garlic Naan was perfectly soft and buttery, and loaded with garlic. Rogan Josh is usually made with lamb, but we decided to try it with goat and loved it. Be warned that the goat is a little more work as it is on the bone. In India it is common to eat with your hands (even curries) and not considered impolite. If you get anything with goat, feel free to use your hands to remove the meat from the bone as it’s easier. Rogan Josh is a creamy curry with great depth of flavor, loads of spices including Kashmiri chilis which make it reddish-brown and a little spicy. There’s lots of extra sauce to spoon over rice, or […]
In this recipe, we are transforming simple ingredients into an elevated flatbread that is ideal for enjoying on these cooler December evenings. All of the elements involved in this sausage, pesto & peperonata flatbread are not only complementary together, but they are equally as delicious when used in different applications. The pesto can be tossed with your favorite pasta or served alongside arancini (we actually did this for Thanksgiving this year and it was a hit). Peperonata can serve as an easy appetizer spooned onto crusty slices of bread, or as a tangy topper for sandwiches, crispy cutlets or even with a steak. You can use any type of flatbread for this recipe. On a busy weeknight when time is of the essence, I suggest grabbing a flatbread option that is already baked in the package – naan could even work well here. Rollin’ Oats Natural Food Market sells a few different variations like O’Doughs flatbread, which happens to be gluten free and vegan. If you’d rather bake a homemade or store-bought dough and have the time, I recommend going for it. This way, you can control the thickness of your flatbread. The bake time is only about ten extra minutes, if you opt for this route. The ground Italian sausage brings the the whole flatbread together with its subtle touch of savory spice. Ground Italian sausage is my preference, but if you’d rather a fully-cooked version, you can’t go wrong. Simply slice it into rounds and arrange before baking the flatbread in the oven. Sausage, Pesto & Peperonata Flatbread Recipe In this recipe, sweet and sour peperonata, pesto and sausage are combined to create an elevated take on flatbread. You don't have to make your flatbread dough from scratch in order to get the most out of this recipe – there are plenty of suitable store-bought options available. Pesto5 cups basil (5 packed cups, fresh)3/4 cup parmesan cheese (finely grated)1/2 cup pine nuts3 garlic cloves (peeled and smashed)3/4 cup olive oil1 tsp salt (plus more, to taste)1 tbsp lemon juice (from 1/2 of a small lemon (optional))Peperonata3 bell peppers (about 3 cups, mix of colors of choice, thinly sliced)1/2 cup olive oil1/2 white onion (medium in size, sliced thin)4 garlic cloves (peeled, smashed and sliced very thin)5 sprigs fresh thyme2 1/2 tbsp red wine vinegarsalt (to taste)Flatbread Assembly1 flatbread (homemade or a mix like Bob's Redmill or an already prepared flatbread of choice (naan would work great too))1 lb cooked ground sausage1/2 cup parmesan cheese (grated )basil or parsley (chopped (optional)) PestoHeat your oven to 325F and spread your pine nuts on a parchment lined baking sheet. Toast for 6 minutes. Add pine nuts and all pesto recipe ingredients, except the oil, (including lemon, if using – this will add a touch of brightness) to a food processor or high powered blender. Blend or process on high while slowly streaming in the oil until the pesto is smooth. Add more salt as needed. Set pesto aside until you're ready to assemble the flatbread.PeperonataHeat oil in a large pot or dutch oven over medium heat. Add in peppers, onion, garlic and thyme and cook for 6 minutes. Reduce the heat to medium-low to cook the mixture slowly until peppers and onions soften, about 25 minutes. Discard thyme sprigs, stir in red wine vinegar and season with salt to taste. Set aside.Flatbread AssemblyHeat oven to 400F. If using a homemade or store bought dough, roll it out onto a parchment-lined baking sheet to your desired thickness. Top with a few spoon fulls of pesto (evenly dispersed), cooked ground sausage and half of the grated parmesan. Bake for 20 minutes. If using an already baked flatbread or other bread like naan, repeat steps with pesto, sausage and parmesan and bake for only 10 minutes.Remove flatbread from the oven and increase oven heat to 425F. Top flatbread with peperonata and remaining grated parmesan. Bake for another 6-8 minutes.Carefully remove the flatbread from the oven, drizzle with more pesto and garnish with chopped basil or parsley.Slice flatbread as desired and serve. Appetizer, Dinner, Main Course, Main DishAmerican, Cajun, ItalianSausage, Pesto & Peperonata Flatbread
French and Moroccan cuisine are two genres of food that we currently do not have enough of in the St. Petersburg area. Because of this, it is no surprise that the community has welcomed the newly-opened permanent location of Cybel French Moroccan Restaurant on 5th Ave N. in Kenwood with open arms. Cybel is actually the only French Moroccan restaurant in the area. Chef Touf, who we had the pleasure of meeting during our meal at Cybel, is the mind behind the operation. Chef started his professional cooking journey in LA as a private chef for a number of athletes and celebrities. This operation then transformed into a catering company. In 2023 Chef Touf brought Cybel to life as a ghost kitchen located at Foodie Labs, which acts as a culinary incubator. After eight months at Foodies Labs, Chef Touf announced in July that a new home for Cybel would be coming soon. On November 1st, their brick and mortar location opened to the public. Why French Moroccan fare? Chef Touf’s inspiration behind serving French Moroccan in his restaurant stems from his years spent in Morocco as a child. During this time, he grew very fond of the cuisine. Currently, Cybel is open for dinner Tuesday through Sunday beginning at 5:00PM, however, they just announced on November 19th that brunch would be debuting this weekend (weekend of November 23rd) from 11:00AM – 3:30PM. The brunch will be in collaboration with Brewed Awakenings, which operates out of Cybel’s restaurant Wednesday – Monday from 7:00AM – 3:00PM. The brunch menu will feature dishes like Tagine Shakshuka, Za’atar Avocado Tartine and Merguez, just to name a few. Intriguing coffee beverages by Brewed Awakening include cold brew lemonade, a thai latte, matcha latte and an oat latte with your flavor choice of lavender or cinnamon banana bread. Reservations are now available. As for Cybel’s standard dinner menu, you’ll find an array of shareable items, vibrant salads, mouthwatering entrees like tagines, kabobs, shawarma and a must-order French taco, a selection of pitas and various sides that are not to be overlooked. We tried to order something from each section and what made this easy is the fact that a number of the entrees offer some of the sides and salads. This was ultra convenient and allowed us the opportunity to try some items that we otherwise may have not ordered on our own. Because Cybel does not serve alcohol, they encourage guests to bring their own. That’s right – BYOB. When you’re planning your visit to Cybel, make sure to bring along one of your favorite bottles to enjoy along side your meal. For their new brunch, I suggest a bottle of delicious bubbles to complement your leisurely weekend dining experience. As I mentioned earlier, when talking about their new brunch, Cybel encourages reservations. These can be secured via their website here. We arrived at Cybel on a Friday night for our 6:00PM reservation. Because we checked in before the rush, we had our pick of sitting inside or outside. The interior of the space has approximately ten tables and the exterior offers a handful more – we opted for a two top inside. Around 6:30PM, the restaurant was packed both inside and out. It was bustling which kept the staff quite busy. Our server was so attentive, especially considering how busy they were. After we placed our food order and received our appetizer, she informed us that the mains may take a bit longer than expected, but that’s never an issue for us. We really wanted to try a number of the items from the starters section of the menu and the Un peu de tout was absolutely perfect for that. It is great to share between a few people and includes falafel, labneh, hummus, Moroccan ratatouille, tabbouleh with zaatar pita bread. Each element of this platter was delightful in its own way. The falafel had perfect texture and was great with a dollop of labneh for a premium bite. Ratatouille isn’t usually a favorite of mine, but this rendition was a loaded hit of flavor that surprised both me and my husband. I highly suggest ordering this app, regardless of how many folks you’re dining with, because it is just enough to enjoy before the mains, you get a variety of bites and is as wonderful as it sounds. Our entrees didn’t take as long as expected and arrived in a timely manner. The French Taco (more like a burrito) is a must-order in my opinion. It has its own menu where you select your meat, vegetables, sauce and type of fry (the fries are served in the taco) – regular or gourmet (gourmet = extra crispy for texture). After some deliberating, we decided on the jerk chicken with onion, tomato, shredded lettuce and the six sick sauce. The six sick sauce (additional $3) is a blend of all six of their sauces in one which makes for an incredible sauce that hits all of the notes (I know, it sounds like a lot, but you have to trust me here). This item could definitely be split between two people, as it is very large. The next entree of note that we ordered is the Chicken Shawarma. It comes with marinated shawarma that is sliced thin and served with garlic sauce (Toum), Mediterranean rice and parsley salad. This was my entree of choice and I’m so glad that I selected it as it was light, fresh and chock-full of savory flavor and I couldn’t get enough of the garlic sauce. It was like a build your own bite experience which also makes this an entree that could easily be shared. We had the leftovers the next day with some pita and that whole experience was equally as tasty as the first. We really wanted to give the beef kabobs a try and the pita as our kabob vessel with a side of fries and it was a home-run. It arrived dressed with […]
The temperature here in Florida may still be quite warm, but it is in fact fall and I can’t help but shift into comfort-cooking mode. For me, that means that lots of pasta dishes and comforting soups are frequently in the dinner rotation. A few months ago, I made stuffed rigatoni for the first time and fell in love with both the process of making it and the end result. The rigatoni was filled with a mixture of ricotta, mozzarella and provolone cheese and minced mortadella and was served in a spicy tomato sauce. While enjoying this dish, a number of alternative filling possibilities entered my mind and a simple mixture of ricotta and mushroom was one of the first. I’ve been making marinara at least once (sometimes twice) per month, usually on Sundays, for at least ten years now. Over the course of these ten years, tweaks and changes have been made to the recipe and a few years ago, I landed on what works best for my taste. The ingredient list is simple, but depends heavily on quality ingredients – like premium whole peeled tomatoes, 24 month parmigiano reggiono rinds and some good red wine. Luckily, Rollin’ Oats is a mecca for premium ingredients. For the sauce, they have a few canned tomato offerings that I recommend, like Cento and also organic variations from Muir Glen and Bionature. And we all know that they have a wonderful selection of great wines to choose from and a few experts on their staff to help you make a selection. You’re only using 1/4 cup in this recipe, but I always recommend using a wine that you would drink when cooking. You could undoubtedly assemble this recipe on a weekday, however, I think it is best enjoyed on a slow Saturday or Sunday. In the recipe, I suggest cooking the sauce for at least an hour, but you can definitely allow it to simmer for up to a few hours. The smell of marinara flowing through the home is one of my favorite scents ever. You can use this sauce in many other recipes like meatballs, chicken parmesan or other pastas of course like spaghetti. Ricotta & Mushroom Stuffed Rigatoni Recipe This comforting pasta dish is comprised of rigatoni that is stuffed with a mix of creamy ricotta cheese and savory mushrooms that is then baked in a simple marinara sauce. ovensafe skillet or large dutch ovenBlender Marinara1 tbsp olive oil1/2 white onion (medium in size, roughly chopped)3 garlic cloves (peeled and crushed)1 tsp dried oregano2 tbsp tomato paste1/4 cup red wine (pick a red that you would drink)2 bay leaves1 28oz can crushed or whole peeled tomatoesparmesan rind (optional)1 tsp salt (plus more to taste)Ricotta & Mushroom Filling1 tbsp olive oiltsp tsp salt (divided)8 oz mushrooms (diced into very small pieces – shiitake, baby bella, or most any other mushroom will work)10 oz ricotta cheese1 eggRigatoni & Assembly16 oz rigatoni (you may have leftover rigatoni – save them for another use)1 tbsp olive oil1/4 cup parmesan (grated)1/4 cup fresh basil (roughly chopped or torn) Ricotta & Mushroom FillingHeat 1 tbsp olive oil over medium heat. Add mushrooms and 1/2 tsp salt and cook, stirring occasionally, until liquid from mushrooms has evaporated completely – about 10-12 minutes.Add cooked mushrooms to a bowl with ricotta, beaten egg and remaining 1 tsp salt. Allow mixture to cool in the refrigerator while you prepare the marinara.After filling has cooled for an hour, add filling to a sandwich-sized ziplock bag. Cut a very small opening into one corner of the bag (smaller than the size of the opening of the rigatoni).MarinaraHeat a dutch oven or pot that is medium in size over medium heat. Add 1 tbsp olive oil and chopped onion. Cook onion, stirring occasionally, until it softens (6-8 minutes). Season with 1/2 tsp salt.Add in crushed garlic cloves and dried oregano and cook for one minute, stirring constantly, until fragrant – about one minute. Stir in tomato paste and cook until it takes on a brick red color. Pour in wine, deglaze pan, and allow the wine to reduce for 2-3 minutes. Add bay leaves, tomatoes, parmesan rinds (if using) and another 1/2 tsp salt to the pot and stir to combine.Bring marinara to a simmer, reduce heat to medium low, and allow sauce to simmer gently for about one hour. Season with more salt as needed. After an hour, discard bay leaves and parmesan rinds and blend sauce with an immersion blender or in a high powered blender until smooth. Add sauce to a large oven-safe skillet (like cast iron) or a large dutch oven and set aside until ready to fill rigatoni.Rigatoni & AssemblyHeat oven to 350 F. Cook pasta 1-2 minutes less than package instructions (you want an al dente texture to keep the rigatoni from ripping – they will cook further in the final steps of the recipe in the oven). Strain and rinse with cold water, add to a large bowl and toss with 1 tbsp olive oil to keep the rigatoni from sticking together.One at a time, pipe filling mixture into each piece of rigatoni and arrange in a single layer in prepared skillet/dutch oven with pureed marinara until you run out of room (you want to nestle them into the sauce so they are mostly covered).Repeat with remaining pieces of rigatoni. Distribute half of grated parmesan over the stuffed rigatoni in marinara.Place skillet into the oven until cheese melts and begins to take on a light golden color- 20-25 minutes. Top with remaining grated parmesan and basil and serve immediately. Dinner, Main Course, Main DishAmerican, ItalianRicotta & Mushroom Stuffed Rigatoni
Recipes
In this recipe, we are transforming simple ingredients into an elevated flatbread that is ideal for enjoying on these cooler December evenings. All of the elements involved in this sausage, pesto & peperonata flatbread are not only complementary together, but they are equally as delicious when used in different applications. The pesto can be tossed with your favorite pasta or served alongside arancini (we actually did this for Thanksgiving this year and it was a hit). Peperonata can serve as an easy appetizer spooned onto crusty slices of bread, or as a tangy topper for sandwiches, crispy cutlets or even with a steak. You can use any type of flatbread for this recipe. On a busy weeknight when time is of the essence, I suggest grabbing a flatbread option that is already baked in the package – naan could even work well here. Rollin’ Oats Natural Food Market sells a few different variations like O’Doughs flatbread, which happens to be gluten free and vegan. If you’d rather bake a homemade or store-bought dough and have the time, I recommend going for it. This way, you can control the thickness of your flatbread. The bake time is only about ten extra minutes, if you opt for this route. The ground Italian sausage brings the the whole flatbread together with its subtle touch of savory spice. Ground Italian sausage is my preference, but if you’d rather a fully-cooked version, you can’t go wrong. Simply slice it into rounds and arrange before baking the flatbread in the oven. Sausage, Pesto & Peperonata Flatbread Recipe In this recipe, sweet and sour peperonata, pesto and sausage are combined to create an elevated take on flatbread. You don't have to make your flatbread dough from scratch in order to get the most out of this recipe – there are plenty of suitable store-bought options available. Pesto5 cups basil (5 packed cups, fresh)3/4 cup parmesan cheese (finely grated)1/2 cup pine nuts3 garlic cloves (peeled and smashed)3/4 cup olive oil1 tsp salt (plus more, to taste)1 tbsp lemon juice (from 1/2 of a small lemon (optional))Peperonata3 bell peppers (about 3 cups, mix of colors of choice, thinly sliced)1/2 cup olive oil1/2 white onion (medium in size, sliced thin)4 garlic cloves (peeled, smashed and sliced very thin)5 sprigs fresh thyme2 1/2 tbsp red wine vinegarsalt (to taste)Flatbread Assembly1 flatbread (homemade or a mix like Bob's Redmill or an already prepared flatbread of choice (naan would work great too))1 lb cooked ground sausage1/2 cup parmesan cheese (grated )basil or parsley (chopped (optional)) PestoHeat your oven to 325F and spread your pine nuts on a parchment lined baking sheet. Toast for 6 minutes. Add pine nuts and all pesto recipe ingredients, except the oil, (including lemon, if using – this will add a touch of brightness) to a food processor or high powered blender. Blend or process on high while slowly streaming in the oil until the pesto is smooth. Add more salt as needed. Set pesto aside until you're ready to assemble the flatbread.PeperonataHeat oil in a large pot or dutch oven over medium heat. Add in peppers, onion, garlic and thyme and cook for 6 minutes. Reduce the heat to medium-low to cook the mixture slowly until peppers and onions soften, about 25 minutes. Discard thyme sprigs, stir in red wine vinegar and season with salt to taste. Set aside.Flatbread AssemblyHeat oven to 400F. If using a homemade or store bought dough, roll it out onto a parchment-lined baking sheet to your desired thickness. Top with a few spoon fulls of pesto (evenly dispersed), cooked ground sausage and half of the grated parmesan. Bake for 20 minutes. If using an already baked flatbread or other bread like naan, repeat steps with pesto, sausage and parmesan and bake for only 10 minutes.Remove flatbread from the oven and increase oven heat to 425F. Top flatbread with peperonata and remaining grated parmesan. Bake for another 6-8 minutes.Carefully remove the flatbread from the oven, drizzle with more pesto and garnish with chopped basil or parsley.Slice flatbread as desired and serve. Appetizer, Dinner, Main Course, Main DishAmerican, Cajun, ItalianSausage, Pesto & Peperonata Flatbread
The temperature here in Florida may still be quite warm, but it is in fact fall and I can’t help but shift into comfort-cooking mode. For me, that means that lots of pasta dishes and comforting soups are frequently in the dinner rotation. A few months ago, I made stuffed rigatoni for the first time and fell in love with both the process of making it and the end result. The rigatoni was filled with a mixture of ricotta, mozzarella and provolone cheese and minced mortadella and was served in a spicy tomato sauce. While enjoying this dish, a number of alternative filling possibilities entered my mind and a simple mixture of ricotta and mushroom was one of the first. I’ve been making marinara at least once (sometimes twice) per month, usually on Sundays, for at least ten years now. Over the course of these ten years, tweaks and changes have been made to the recipe and a few years ago, I landed on what works best for my taste. The ingredient list is simple, but depends heavily on quality ingredients – like premium whole peeled tomatoes, 24 month parmigiano reggiono rinds and some good red wine. Luckily, Rollin’ Oats is a mecca for premium ingredients. For the sauce, they have a few canned tomato offerings that I recommend, like Cento and also organic variations from Muir Glen and Bionature. And we all know that they have a wonderful selection of great wines to choose from and a few experts on their staff to help you make a selection. You’re only using 1/4 cup in this recipe, but I always recommend using a wine that you would drink when cooking. You could undoubtedly assemble this recipe on a weekday, however, I think it is best enjoyed on a slow Saturday or Sunday. In the recipe, I suggest cooking the sauce for at least an hour, but you can definitely allow it to simmer for up to a few hours. The smell of marinara flowing through the home is one of my favorite scents ever. You can use this sauce in many other recipes like meatballs, chicken parmesan or other pastas of course like spaghetti. Ricotta & Mushroom Stuffed Rigatoni Recipe This comforting pasta dish is comprised of rigatoni that is stuffed with a mix of creamy ricotta cheese and savory mushrooms that is then baked in a simple marinara sauce. ovensafe skillet or large dutch ovenBlender Marinara1 tbsp olive oil1/2 white onion (medium in size, roughly chopped)3 garlic cloves (peeled and crushed)1 tsp dried oregano2 tbsp tomato paste1/4 cup red wine (pick a red that you would drink)2 bay leaves1 28oz can crushed or whole peeled tomatoesparmesan rind (optional)1 tsp salt (plus more to taste)Ricotta & Mushroom Filling1 tbsp olive oiltsp tsp salt (divided)8 oz mushrooms (diced into very small pieces – shiitake, baby bella, or most any other mushroom will work)10 oz ricotta cheese1 eggRigatoni & Assembly16 oz rigatoni (you may have leftover rigatoni – save them for another use)1 tbsp olive oil1/4 cup parmesan (grated)1/4 cup fresh basil (roughly chopped or torn) Ricotta & Mushroom FillingHeat 1 tbsp olive oil over medium heat. Add mushrooms and 1/2 tsp salt and cook, stirring occasionally, until liquid from mushrooms has evaporated completely – about 10-12 minutes.Add cooked mushrooms to a bowl with ricotta, beaten egg and remaining 1 tsp salt. Allow mixture to cool in the refrigerator while you prepare the marinara.After filling has cooled for an hour, add filling to a sandwich-sized ziplock bag. Cut a very small opening into one corner of the bag (smaller than the size of the opening of the rigatoni).MarinaraHeat a dutch oven or pot that is medium in size over medium heat. Add 1 tbsp olive oil and chopped onion. Cook onion, stirring occasionally, until it softens (6-8 minutes). Season with 1/2 tsp salt.Add in crushed garlic cloves and dried oregano and cook for one minute, stirring constantly, until fragrant – about one minute. Stir in tomato paste and cook until it takes on a brick red color. Pour in wine, deglaze pan, and allow the wine to reduce for 2-3 minutes. Add bay leaves, tomatoes, parmesan rinds (if using) and another 1/2 tsp salt to the pot and stir to combine.Bring marinara to a simmer, reduce heat to medium low, and allow sauce to simmer gently for about one hour. Season with more salt as needed. After an hour, discard bay leaves and parmesan rinds and blend sauce with an immersion blender or in a high powered blender until smooth. Add sauce to a large oven-safe skillet (like cast iron) or a large dutch oven and set aside until ready to fill rigatoni.Rigatoni & AssemblyHeat oven to 350 F. Cook pasta 1-2 minutes less than package instructions (you want an al dente texture to keep the rigatoni from ripping – they will cook further in the final steps of the recipe in the oven). Strain and rinse with cold water, add to a large bowl and toss with 1 tbsp olive oil to keep the rigatoni from sticking together.One at a time, pipe filling mixture into each piece of rigatoni and arrange in a single layer in prepared skillet/dutch oven with pureed marinara until you run out of room (you want to nestle them into the sauce so they are mostly covered).Repeat with remaining pieces of rigatoni. Distribute half of grated parmesan over the stuffed rigatoni in marinara.Place skillet into the oven until cheese melts and begins to take on a light golden color- 20-25 minutes. Top with remaining grated parmesan and basil and serve immediately. Dinner, Main Course, Main DishAmerican, ItalianRicotta & Mushroom Stuffed Rigatoni
Elevate your appetizer game with these beef kofta skewers that are laced with irresistible spices and baked to juicy perfection. A drizzle of zesty toum sauce adds a garlicky kick, while a cucumber and tomato salad brings a refreshing crunch that complements the meat beautifully. Serve this all with some warm naan bread to round out the dish. Kofta is a popular Middle Eastern dish that is typically made from ground beef, lamb or chicken that is mixed with spices, herbs and often garlic and onion. The mixture is then formed onto skewers and usually grilled or sometimes baked. Kofta is often served with rice, flatbreads, vibrant salads and a sauce like tahini or toum. There are many different variations and it is a beloved dish across many different cultures. I like to serve kofta as an appetizer for a group and often as an entree for my husband and I. My sauce of preference with kofta is usually a homemade toum sauce. Toum sauce is a recent discovery of mine that I had while dining with friends and after one taste, I knew that I loved it and needed to recreate it. It’s a creamy and flavor-packed condiment that is made from a few simple ingredients – a head of garlic, neutral oil, lemon juice and salt. The mixture is formed in a food processor until a creamy sauce forms (similar to the consistency of yogurt). We use ground beef in this kofta variation – a very high quality organic and grass-fed ground beef that can be found at Rollin’ Oats. They have a few different options, but I prefer the Simply Balanced 90/10 selection. Quality is always of the utmost importance to me when it comes to sourcing any ingredient that I use and I can always trust Rollin’ Oats to have the absolute best. Beef Kofta with Toum Sauce Recipe Savor the spiced flavors of juicy beef kofta paired with a garlicky, creamy toum sauce that elevates this Middle Eastern dish to a whole new level. skewers Beef Kofta1 lb ground beef1/4 cup white onion (minced)2 tsp garlic (minced)1/4 cup parsley and mint (finely chopped)1 tbsp olive oil2 tsp all spice2 tsp paprika1 tsp cumin1 tsp coriander 1 tsp salt1/2 tsp cinnamon1/2 tsp black pepperToum Sauce1 cup garlic cloves (peeled)3 cups neutral oil (grape seed, sunflower, vegetable or canola)1/2 cup lemon juice2 tsps Kosher saltCucumber & Tomato Salad1 tomato (ripe, medium in size & diced)1/2 cup cucumber (diced)1/4 cup basil (finely chopped)1/2 tsp salt (plus more to taste)To Servenaan breadlemon wedges Toum SauceSlice the garlic cloves in half lengthwise and remove any green sprouts. Transfer the sliced garlic cloves into a food processor and add the kosher salt to the garlic cloves. Process for a minute until the garlic becomes finely minced. Make sure to scrape down the sides of the food processor afterwards. While the food processor is running, slowly pour one to two tablespoons of oil, then stop and scrape down the bowl. Continue adding another tablespoon or two until the garlic starts looking creamy.Once the garlic looks emulsified by the few tablespoons of oil, increase the speed of pouring the oil and alternate with the ½ cup of lemon juice until all the oil and lemon juice is incorporated. This will take about 15 minutes to complete.Transfer the sauce into a glass container and cover with a paper towel in the fridge overnight. Makes about 4 cups. The next day, replace the paper towel with an airtight lid and keep in the fridge for up to 3 months.Cucumber & Tomato SaladCombine all ingredients in a bowl, season with salt and refrigerate until the kofta is finished.KoftaIf you're using wooden skewers, soak them in water for at least 20 minutes. This will prevent burning. Combine all kofta ingredients in a medium-sized bowl with your hands until everything is mixed well. Refrigerate the mixture for 30 minutes. Heat the oven to 450F. Place a wire rack onto a baking sheet and brush it with olive oil. After the mixture has been in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes, divide it into four even-sized portions. Form each portion into a snake-like shape around each skewer.Bake the kofta for 13-15 minutes or until the beef is cooked through and beginning to brown on top.To ServeServe kofta on a platter with naan, cucumber and tomato salad, toum and lemon wedges. Appetizer, Dinner, Main DishMiddle EasternKofta, Toum Sauce, Baked Kofta
Low effort and high reward is the name of the game with this take on slow-roasted salmon. The slow-roasting process ensures tender and flakey salmon that melts in your mouth with each bite. The addition of citrus makes this dish quite refreshing while the chili crunch sprinkles in bold and spicy notes. Though the ingredients involved are minimal, together they are the utmost well-balanced. There isn’t a ton of produce in season right now in Florida, but citrus, including orange varietals and grapefruit are goods that you’ll find plenty of during this time of year. Marrying together the invigorating flavors in citrus with a high-quality, fatty piece of wild salmon is quite lovely. The chili crunch aids in adding some texture and the torn fresh dill (or basil) rounds out the dish. Avocado, which is also in season in September, pairs well with all of these ingredients too. If you’d like to also incorporate that, use 1/2 of a ripe avocado and slice it into thin pieces. You can certainly go the extra mile by making your own variation of chili crunch or chili crisp (trust me, it’s much easier than you may think!), but there are plenty of solid options on grocery store shelves these days. One of my favorites is from Momofuku and you can find this at Rollin’ Oats (it’s actually on sale currently). They offer a regular chili crunch, spicy and also a hot honey version. Another reputable brand at Rollin’ Oats is by Mr. Bing – they have a mild and spicy option. When it comes to selecting your salmon, I always suggest reaching for the wild caught versus the farm raised. Rollin’ Oats doesn’t have a dedicated seafood counter; however, they offer quality frozen wild caught salmon that works great for this dish. Just make sure to safely thaw the salmon prior to roasting it. Slow Roasted Salmon with Citrus & Spicy Chili Crunch Recipe Discover a new favorite low-effort dinner with this slow-roasted salmon which is paired with vibrant bits of citrus and a spicy assist from chili crunch. 16 ounces salmon (skin on and preferably wild-caught – 1 large piece or two 8 ounce pieces are recommended)1 tsp olive oil1/2 lemon (sliced into thin rounds)1 grapefruit (peel and pith removed and cut into thin rounds and then into halves and quarters)1 orange (peel and pith removed and cut into thin rounds and then into halves and quarters)1/2 tsp salt (plus more, to taste)2 tbsp chili crunch (plus more as needed – choose your favorite brand – I love Momofoku which can be found at Rollin' Oats)dill or basil (fresh & torn into smaller pieces (garnish, optional))avocado (sliced (optional)) Heat oven to 250F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Place the salmon on the lined baking sheet brush with olive oil, season with salt and top with the lemon slices.Roast the salmon for an hour and remove from the oven – the salmon should be quite tender and should pull easily away from the salmon's skin in pieces. Don't worry about keeping the salmon filet in one piece – we want it to flake a bit into chunks.To plate, arrange the flaky salmon pieces with citrus and avocado (if using) on a serving platter – there is no right or wrong way to do this, so feel free to get creative with your plating. Top with 2-3 spoon-fulls of chili crunch and garnish with torn dill or basil. Season with more salt as desired. Dinner, Main Course, Main DishAmericanSlow Roasted Salmon, Slow Roasted Salmon with Citrus & Chili Crunch
Fresh Corn Polenta with Pickled Shrimp brings together the sweetness of summer corn and the tangy notes of pickled shrimp. This recipe offers a brighter twist on traditional comfort food. This take on polenta acts as an idyllic canvas for the zesty shrimp which are pickled and marinated in a myriad of ingredients which include, but are not limited to: rice wine vinegar, citrus, crushed red pepper flakes and garlic. It’s a perfect dish for highlighting popular ingredients that are used a lot in summer cooking. Creating the fresh corn polenta could not be more simple and only requires a few ingredients that you probably already have on hand. I first made this polenta a couple of weeks ago after I picked up some corn from a farmer’s market in the area. I was told that the corn had just been harvested the day prior from a farm here in Florida. The method for making the fresh corn polenta was something that I had been wanting to experiment with. It all starts by peeling the corn and then grating it with the large holes on a boxed grater. From there, the grated corn mixture is then simmered with a couple of pats of butter and some salt until the polenta thickens a bit. This process only takes about ten minutes. The polenta is then finished with a squeeze of fresh lime. Initially, I had planned to top the fresh corn polenta with poached lobster and some chive butter (which I will be trying soon), but then I found some inspiration for pickled shrimp from a recent episode of a food-related show on television (The Lost Kitchen, for those interested). The shrimp are first poached in some water, lemon and salt. Then, they are placed in a pickling mixture in the refrigerator for a few hours (and up to 24 hours). The pickling mixture makes for tangy and flavorful shrimp that not only work well on this polenta, but also with many other things. These shrimp would work well on some toasty sourdough, tossed in a salad, nestled in some rice or simply on their own as an easy appetizer. For the shrimp, I always strive to use wild caught, but use whatever you can find. Rollin’ Oats has great quality frozen shrimp by Baywinds and Wixter Seafood. Simply thaw the shrimp and devein them with the shells on if they aren’t already deveined (this is easier to do than you think – use a wooden skewer or toothpick, poke it through the side of the shrimp in the middle towards the top and slowly thread and pull the vein out – give it a google for a tutorial). You can also use shrimp that are already peeled and deveined too, but cooking the shrimp with their shell on adds to the flavor and prevents overcooking of the shrimp. Fresh Corn Polenta with Pickled Shrimp Recipe Put summer's fresh corn to good use with this fresh corn polenta recipe. The pickled shrimp add a zesty zing when served atop the creamy polenta. glass bowl or glass Tupperware Poaching the Shrimp12 shrimp (medium to large in size – shell on, but deveined (optional, you can use peeled shrimp if you prefer))6 cups water6 cups ice1 lemon (cut in half)2 1/2 tbsp saltPickling the Shrimp3/4 cup rice wine vinegar2 tbsp sugar2 garlic cloves (peeled and smashed)1/2 tsp crushed red pepper1 dried bay leaf1/2 cup olive oilt tsp worcestershire 1 tsp salt1/2 tsp hot sauce (use your preference – I usually opt for Diamond Crystal)1/2 lemon (sliced into small wedges)1/4 cup red onion (sliced thin)Fresh Corn Polenta4 ears corn (husk and silk removed)2 tbsp butter1/2 tsp salt (plus more to taste)1/2 limeDish Assemblymicro-greens (for garnish – fresh dill would work well too (optional)) Pickling the ShrimpAdd vinegar, sugar, garlic, crushed red pepper and bay leaf to a microwave-safe bowl or glass measuring cup. Heat mixture for two minutes, stir to combine and cool completely in the refrigerator (30 minutes to an hour).When mixture is cool, stir in olive oil, worcestershire, hot sauce and salt. Then, mix in lemon wedges and sliced onions. Set aside until poached shrimp are ready.Poaching the ShrimpAdd water, juice lemon and lemon halves and salt to a medium pot and bring to a boil.Add deveined shrimp, remove pot from heat and allow shrimp to poach for 5 minutes (or until they turn pink).Add in ice and allow to sit for another 10 minutes.Remove shrimp from pot and discard water and lemon. Peel shrimp (leave tails on if desired, optional) and place into glass bowl or Tupperware for pickling.Pour prepared pickling mixture over the shrimp. Cover shrimp and place in the refrigerator for at least three hours and up to 24 hours.Fresh Corn PolentaGrate corn on the cob with the large holes of a box grater over a medium-size bowl.Heat grated corn, butter and salt over medium heat. Cook, stirring occasionally, until corn mixture thickens – about ten minutes. Taste and season with more salt as needed (polenta should now taste a bit more rich). Remove from heat and stir in juice of 1/2 lime.AssemblyTo plate, add 1/4 corn polenta mixture to each bowl, top with pickled shrimp and garnish with micro-greens or fresh dill. Appetizer, Dinner, Main DishAmericanFresh Corn Polenta, Pickled Shrimp
I’ve eaten pizza in every place in St. Petersburg and Nicko’s is good. It’s not the best in St. Petersburg and it’s not close to NY pizza. The Philly sub I had was below average. Now, the staff were super nice, the vibe in the restaurant was upbeat and the price is fine. It’s also in a pretty bad neighborhood that hopefully gets better with time. I wish Nicko’s the best, but the writer here is exaggerating or just hasn’t eaten a lot of good pizza.
It’s too bad you feel that way. I happen to be a certified pizza judge and have eaten tons of pizza. And it is not a Philly Cheesesteak. It’s their version of a steak and cheese sandwich. If you think it’s going to be a Philly Cheesesteak of course you wouldn’t like it. I loved it.
I visited slice of the burg on your recommendation and found the pizza to be awful. I’m from New York and there’s no way in hell that that pizza is anything like what you would get no matter what pizza joint you went to in New York City you ought to be ashamed to call themselves New York style pizza I had the everything Pizza it had very little extra toppings and it was just plain awful I left half the slice there
You are not commenting on our review of Slice of the Burg, that was written by Kevin Godbee, not by me. This review is of Nicko’s. If you took the time to read the entire review of Slice of the Burg, you would see that we liked some pizza but not all. They do not have an ‘everything’ pizza on their menu and we did not review or endorse that. So that’s on you. Sorry you had a bad experience. The only thing Kevin said was close to NY style was the cheese pizza.
I have pizza at Nikko’s at least once a week. Their pizza is unique and delicious. The pizza is tossed NY style and to me the crust has a Chicago style flavor and texture. I love it. You can tell quality ingredients are being used when oil weeps out of the cheese. Theirs does.