Malio’s Beach House: Coastal Fine Dining Done Right

ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:
Malio’s Beach House: Coastal Fine Dining Done Right

Malio’s Beach House brings a touch of timeless steakhouse charm to the relaxed shores of St. Pete Beach, offering a sophisticated ambiance and menu comprised of elevated classics. Most folks likely know Mailio’s as the downtown Tampa steakhouse that has been around since 1969. Malio’s Beach House though has only been open since February. While the menus are similar, the atmosphere in the two locations is very different. Set on Gulf Blvd, Malio’s Beach House provides a beachside getaway where high-quality steaks, seafood and cocktails take center stage.

The front entrance of Malio's Beach House
The front entrance of Malio’s Beach House

Historically speaking, the beaches in September are usually a little more quiet; therefore, I did not initially intend on securing a reservation for an early dinner for four on a Saturday. Though, my gut argued otherwise and I pulled up my Open Table app. I was shocked at what I discovered – only one reservation slot was available at 4:00PM. While this is not an ideal dinner time, I was just happy to have a reservation at all.

Upon entering Malio’s Beach House, a subtly lit and intimate atmosphere immediately surrounds you. The interior design is upscale and polished. It is truly an idyllic setting for occasions, an intimate evening on the town or even for those times that you’re just simply looking for a meal that feels special from start to finish. For dining, the restaurant offers a few seating options: an exquisite main dining room with intimate booths and standard tables, a bar and lounge area and also an outdoor patio with lots of tables. Additionally, it’s a great spot for hosting a private event.

Sleek and sophisticated details in the main dining room
Sleek and sophisticated details in the main dining room
Malio's dining room
Malio’s dining room

One of the benefits that came along with our early reservation was the ability to view the beautiful details all throughout Malio’s before it filled up. We were first offered a booth in the dining room, but our party opted for a more laid back option in the lounge area. We were one of the first groups to arrive at the restaurant and within the first half hour, the bar was mostly full and it stayed full throughout the duration of our meal. Parking can be tricky on the beach, but Malio’s has their own dedicated parking lot which has plenty of spots for their diners – even on the busiest of nights.

Bar and lounge area of the restaurant
Bar and lounge area of the restaurant
Framed images hanging in the bar area
Framed images hanging in the bar area

Our evening at Malio’s Beach House began with a round of drinks for the table – Prosecco, Chardonnay, Michelob and a Paper Plane. The execution of the Paper Plane was superb – bright, balanced and slightly bitter-sweet.

Paper Plane and prosecco
Paper Plane and prosecco

The menu at Malio’s Beach House is plentiful with a number of enticing seafood dishes, steaks and more. A member of the staff, Sam, was refilling our waters when he overheard us discussing appetizer options and noted that we mentioned lobster. Malio’s has a Lobster Escargot option under the appetizers and he suggested that if we were thinking about sharing a lobster appetizer between the four of us, we should opt for the whole lobster tail cooked Theresa style with bread crumbs, lemon, butter, white wine and garlic (in large chunks) and served in the lobster shell. It’s an off menu dish that is always available.

ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:
Cocktail and dinner menu
Cocktail and dinner menu
Dinner menu continued and the dessert selections
Dinner menu continued and the dessert selections

We were blown away when this hit the table as the portion size was more than generous – so generous, that we barely even made it through half of the dish. Everything about it was rich and indulgent in the best way possible. The complimentary bread was the perfect vessel for sopping up the decadent sauce on the plate.

MORE FOODIES READING  The Lure Ono - Your One Stop For Grab and Go Sammies, Smoothies and More
Whole lobster tail prepared Theresa Style
Whole lobster tail prepared Theresa Style

The Mozzarella Malzone was also a unanimous choice by the table. Two triangles of fried mozzarella with house-made marinara – a dish like this will always please a crowd. Recently, I have noted many takes on this fried cheese dish and it’s easy to see why. It’s tough to go wrong with breaded and fried cheese in any shape or size.

We started the meal with two appetizers - the whole lobster tail prepared Theresa style and the fried Mozzarella
We started the meal with two appetizers – the whole lobster tail prepared Theresa style and the fried Mozzarella

After we finished the appetizers and our first round of drinks, the inside of Malio’s was buzzing and nearly at capacity in the bar area and in the dining room. Taylor, our fantastic and attentive waitress, visited us again to collect our next drinks – we switched to the Quilt Cabernet from Napa Valley in preparation of our entrees which were soon to arrive.

We could not visit a steakhouse without ordering a steak and the 6oz filet, cooked to a lovely medium rare, was the move. Malio’s proudly serves Creekstone USDA Prime all natural steaks that are hormone and antibiotic free. Each steak is seasoned with herb butter, salt and pepper and served a la carte on a hot plate. The filet was flawless and cooked precisely to temperature.

The 6oz filet
The 6oz filet
The beautiful cook on the filet
The beautiful cook on the filet

Malio’s menu has a 16oz pork chop and if you know my husband, you know that this will always be his choice. When asked about his preferred temperature, he requested medium rare and it’s no surprise that they nailed the cook on this. The pork was juicy and flavorful and the preparation was not fussy. We took half of this home with us and it heated up quite well the next day with a quick sear in a cast iron skillet.

Malio's pork chop
Malio’s pork chop

Because Lobster Escargot was our original lobster desire, we decided to give it a try in order to compare it with the lobster tail that was prepared Theresa style. Malio’s Lobster Escargot is baked in garlic butter and served with toast points. It is plated much like traditional escargot with five total bites. We didn’t leave one bit of it behind. The two lobster dishes were delicious but both very different. I recommend the Theresa style tale with larger groups and the escargot when you just want a taste of lobster.

The lobster escargot
The lobster escargot

My mother was dining with us and her appetite went straight to the crabmeat pasta. This is prepared two different ways – with a marinara or Yankee style in a white wine, garlic and butter sauce. We encouraged her to take the Yankee style route and this proved to be a solid option given the light and delicate flavors of the crabmeat. This dish could’ve used a touch more salt, but was enjoyable otherwise.

The crabmeat pasta dish
The crabmeat pasta dish

Because all of the entrees were a la carte (as expected), we dove headfirst into the sides. It is worth stating that these side dishes are intended for sharing, so they are quite large. As a group, we decided on the smoked Gouda mac & cheese, house made onion rings and the mashed potatoes. All three options were a hit with us. The mac & cheese was indeed the favorite with prominent smokey and savory flavors.

Steakhouse sides are a must - house made onion rings, smoked Gouda mac & cheese and mashed potatoes
Steakhouse sides are a must – house made onion rings, smoked Gouda mac & cheese and mashed potatoes

The desserts at Malio’s are all made in house and the Bananas Foster was highly recommended. Warm Macadamia Banana bread with Häagen-Dazs vanilla bean ice cream – it is such a treat. I would not hesitate to order this again and I appreciate the honest opinions of the incredible staff who helped guide us through our meal.

MORE FOODIES READING  Bohemios: A Flavor-Filled Journey Through Tapas
Malio's Bananas Foster
Malio’s Bananas Foster

Malio’s Beach House has been open for seven solid months now and it’s very apparent that St. Pete Beach is happy to have them. This restaurant has set the bar for fine dining at the beach. The space is gorgeous and thoughtful, the service is graceful and refined and the food speaks for itself.

Malio's Beach House
  • Readers Rating
  • Rated 5 stars
    5 / 5 (12 )
$$$-$$$$
  • Your Rating


  • Malio's Beach House
  • 727-202-6992
  • Steakhouse , Seafood, Fine Dining
    • Wed - Thu 4:00pm - 11:00pm
    • Fri - Sat 4:00pm - 12:00am
    • Sun - 4:00pm - 11:00pm
  • View menu
  • Take Reservations: Yes!
  • 4945 Gulf Blvd, St. Pete Beach, Florida 33706, United States

Elegant steak house featuring classic cuts such as filet mignon and ribeyes, plus seafood and cocktails.

DISCLAIMER: Kevin, Lori, Abby, Haley, Lindsey & Mahika do not dine anonymously (this would be impossible) and we sometimes get free food (though never expected). However, we dine with the locals and we support our own. You will always get honesty in a respectful manner. We do not include any large national or regional chains in our ratings and reviews. We focus on independent locally owned eateries exclusively.

PLEASE NOTE: Reviews reflect a certain moment in time. Some restaurants stay extremely consistent over many years, and some change for the better or worse. Some things that may change are: chefs, recipes, food suppliers, ingredients, philosophies, ownership, etc. We always hope that you have the same good, or great experience we had.
ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:



More Foodies News, Reviews & Recipes


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:
St. Petersburg Foodies