Dive on in to St Pete’s Newest Spot for Seafood – Cheeky’s Raw Bar

ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:
Dive on in to St Pete’s Newest Spot for Seafood – Cheeky’s Raw Bar

Cheeky’s, one of the most recent restaurant additions to the Grand Central District of St. Pete, is creating a splash with its fresh and playful take on seafood and familiar raw bar delights. From an array of oyster varietals and inventive crudos, to familiar seafood classics, Cheeky’s celebrates the bountiful waters of Florida and the east coast. With its laid-back coastal vibe, ice cold drinks and friendly service, Cheeky’s is already becoming a lively hotspot.

Welcome to Cheeky's
Welcome to Cheeky’s
Signage out front near Central AVe
Signage out front near Central Ave

Cheeky’s radiates the charm of classic oyster bars and coastal fish shacks with walls adorned with an extensive collection of nautical memorabilia. A horseshoe bar, with about 20 seats in the middle of Cheeky’s, is the focal point in the space. There are also several banquettes and tables situated throughout the restaurant. While they do not have air conditioning, which was intentional, they do have 20 fans and two swamp coolers. I found that these kept the air flowing and the temperature comfortable during our dinner on a warm Saturday evening. The goal was to achieve an open-air space with a gentle breeze that exudes the allure of a seaside establishment…and in my opinion, they nailed it.

The bar area at Cheeky's
The bar area at Cheeky’s
Decor on the walls at Cheeky's
Decor on the walls at Cheeky’s

Tampa native Nate Siegel is the man responsible for bringing Cheeky’s to life. You may already recognize Nate from his success with Tampa favorites Willa’s and Willa’s Provisions. Upon entering Cheeky’s during our visit, it was great to see Nate there at the front eagerly greeting and chatting with guests.

For now, Cheeky’s is only open for dinner service Wednesday through Sunday, but brunch and lunch are in the works for the near future. Happy hour launches on Wednesday, June 4th and will be offered every day that Cheeky’s is open from 3:00PM – 6:00PM. Reservations are available through Resy, but the restaurant is walk-in friendly and they will do their best to accommodate your party. We had a reservation at 6:00PM and were seated promptly after checking in at the host stand. Throughout our whole meal, the bar remained mostly full and there was a very steady flow of traffic into the restaurant of solo diners and couples, to families and groups out for a good time. If you have little ones, Cheeky’s is very family/child friendly – we noted plenty of kids.

The back tables at Cheeky's
The back tables at Cheeky’s

Our table at Cheeky’s was located between the entrance and the bar, so we had a front row seat to all of the hustle and bustle. Nicholas, who took fantastic care of us during our meal, greeted our table and collected our drink orders. Cheeky’s drink menu is very fun and approachable. Sections include: ice cold martinis, cocktails on tap, frozen drinks, mocktails, party starters, beer and wine and more.

Cheeky's food menu
Cheeky’s food menu
Cheeky's drink menu
Cheeky’s drink menu

It’s no surprise that my eyes immediately went to the martini section where I landed on the Salt & Vinegar Martini with Ford’s Gin (Grey Goose Vodka is also an option) and an olive-wrapped anchovy (it’s actually an anchovy-wrapped olive). The sword cocktail pick was both an amusing and nostalgic touch. This drink is spirit-forward and savory with a touch of acidity – this was a delight.

ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:
Salt & Vinegar Martini
Salt & Vinegar Martini

My husband couldn’t resist the Stiff Stiegl under the party starter section. A Stiegl is a grapefruit beer and it is served alongside a mini negroni. You can enjoy the two drinks separately or you can combine the two in the glass that is provided with this drink (which is what my husband did). The combination of the two drinks makes for a refreshing and enjoyable concoction.

MORE FOODIES READING  Sushi Sho Rexley: More Than Just a "Sho", It's a Culinary Tasting Extravaganza!
Stiff Stiegl before the beer and the mini negroni were combined
Stiff Stiegl before the beer and the mini negroni were combined
Stiff Stiegl
Stiff Stiegl

I brought my mom along for dinner as well and she couldn’t resist a refreshing cocktail from the frozen section. There are four different offerings in this section: Nana Daiq (banana daiquiri with rum, banana and lime), Espresso Martini, Margarita and a Transfusion. Nicholas explained that the Nana Daiq wouldn’t be on the menu much longer as the cocktail in that spot will rotate regularly. At first glance, one would assume that this drink would lean quite sweet, but it was well balanced, easy to drink and a great beverage on a balmy day.

Banana Daiq - this frozen drink will roate regularly
Banana Daiq – this frozen drink will rotate regularly

We ran over the menu with Nicholas and he made a few suggestions which caused us to deviate from our original ordering plan. Spoiler alert – we were ultimately very happy with our selections. A total of six dishes hit our table and we ordered two items at a time. Oysters were a nonnegotiable, as Cheeky’s offers a great selection of three different types and price points of raw oysters available in half or a full dozen. The oysters are listed as Good (Blue Point, Conn.), Better (Katama, Mass) and Best (IROCs, Fla). Additionally, they also have Char-grilled Louisiana Oysters (a total of six). We selected a half dozen of the “Better” oysters. Cheeky’s oysters are served with lemon, cucumber apple mignonette and cocktail sauce. These oysters, from Katama, Mass, were medium-ish in size and had a sweet and creamy bite to them.

The Better Oysters
The Better Oysters
Oysters from Katama, Ma - medium-ish in size and sweet and creamy
Oysters from Katama, Mass – medium-ish in size and sweet and creamy

With the oysters, we also couldn’t resist ordering the Old Bay Pimento Cheese with apples and fried Ritz crackers from the snacks and apps section. We have had other renditions of fried crackers and dips before and we were very keen on this little trio. The apples were an unexpected, yet welcomed vessel for this cheese spread as cheddar cheese and apples are often paired together in various recipes.

Old Bay Pimento Cheeze with fried Ritz crackers and apples
Old Bay Pimento Cheese with fried Ritz crackers and apples

The Cornbread Hushpuppies with Honey Butter and Guava Jelly were one of the suggestions by Nicholas. Crisp exterior, warm and fluffy interior and the honey butter and guava jelly are what made them irresistible.

The Cornbread Hushpuppies with honey butter and guava jelly
The Cornbread Hushpuppies with honey butter and guava jelly

Initially, the Shrimp Cocktail (six total white shrimp with cocktail sauce and lemon) were a part of our starting lineup, but Nicholas mentioned that the Garlic Butter Shrimp was a new addition (and one of his favorites on the menu), so, we followed his lead. The dish is shrimp seared in lemon, herbs and spices and served with grilled bread. Yet, another crowd pleaser. The shrimp were tender, cooked well and the combination of flavors was harmonious. Make sure to soak up all of that delicious liquid with the grilled bread.

Garlic Butter Shrimp with Grilled Bread
Garlic Butter Shrimp with Grilled Bread

At this point, another round of drinks were in order. Cheeky’s has a few cocktails on top, one of them being the Sundowner Negroni with Ford’s Gin Select, Lofi vermouth, coconut water and strawberry. This negroni is smooth and sippable and the strawberry is subtle, which I was happy about – I wasn’t sure what to expect.Under the house cocktails section, there are a few interesting libations like the Cheeky Ricky (Ford’s gin, St. Germaine elderflower, tonic and lime), Spicy Mango Margarita (Don Fulano, Chimoy, Tajin and lime), Florida Jack Tea (Jack Daniel’s, Grand Marnier and lemon) and the China Finder (Lo-Fi, St. George basil and strawberry peppercorn shrub). Ultimately, we decided on a regular Spicy Margarita. It was thirst-quenching with just the right amount of spice. We are looking forward to drinking our way through some of the other cocktails during our next visit.

MORE FOODIES READING  Happy Birthday to Lori at IL Ritorno
Sundowner Negroni
Sundowner Negroni

The last two items that we selected were the Fish and Chips and the Classic Smash Burger. The lobster roll was originally our plan, but Nicholas said that the burgers were very popular (next time you’re mine, lobster roll). On the Classic Smash Burger, you’ll find grilled onions, American cheese, mustard and special sauce with a smash patty sandwiched on a sesame bun with french fries on the side. It’s precisely what you want from a smash burger, ingredient wise, and the patty had a great charred flavor. A Fried Oyster Burger also sits proudly on Cheeky’s menu.  We saw plenty of them being delivered to surrounding tables. This burger is topped with fried oysters, melted cheddar, pickled onions, Bibb lettuce and garlic mayo.

The Smash Burger at Cheeky's
The Smash Burger at Cheeky’s
Cheeky's Smash Burger
Cheeky’s Smash Burger

I love fish & chips, especially when they’re executed well, and Cheeky’s fish & chips have landed a spot on the top of my list. Two large pieces of beer battered cod, malt vinegar aioli and lemon with a side of crispy fries – it makes my mouth water to think about it. The fry on the fish was ideal and the malt vinegar aioli was a superb upgrade from standard tarter sauce. We were all very full when this dish arrived, so we shared one of the large pieces and took the other to-go and it heated up very well the next day.

Fish & Chips
Fish & Chips

Cheeky’s has a really great thing going on with a distinctive take on the oyster bar and fish house concept. The atmosphere is lively, but chill, the food is familiar yet uniquely its own, the beverage program is intriguing without being too fussy and the staff is friendly and attentive. I can, without a doubt, see frequent visits to Cheeky’s in our future.

Cheekys Neighborhood Restaurant & Oyster Bar
  • Readers Rating
  • Rated 5 stars
    5 / 5 (12 )
$$-$$$
  • Your Rating


  • Cheekys Neighborhood Restaurant & Oyster Bar
  • 877-243-3595
  • Oysters , Fresh Seafood, Burgers
    • Sun - 5:00pm - 9:00pm
    • Wed - Thu 5:00pm - 10:00pm
    • Fri - Sat 5:00pm - 11:00pm
  • Take Reservations: Yes!
  • 2823 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, Florida 33713, United States

Cheeky's is a neighborhood seafood restaurant & raw bar set along Central Avenue in St. Pete's Grand Central District.

DISCLAIMER: Kevin, Lori, Abby, Haley, Lindsey & Mahika do not dine anonymously (this would be impossible) and we sometimes get free food (though never expected). However, we dine with the locals and we support our own. You will always get honesty in a respectful manner. We do not include any large national or regional chains in our ratings and reviews. We focus on independent locally owned eateries exclusively.

PLEASE NOTE: Reviews reflect a certain moment in time. Some restaurants stay extremely consistent over many years, and some change for the better or worse. Some things that may change are: chefs, recipes, food suppliers, ingredients, philosophies, ownership, etc. We always hope that you have the same good, or great experience we had.
ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:



More Foodies News, Reviews & Recipes


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ST. PETE FOODIES APPROVED SPONSOR:
St. Petersburg Foodies